The Arcane Alchemist:
Arcane Essence: 0/5 turned in from Spectral Warrior **
Magic Orb: 0/3 turned in from Ancient Deserter **
Fortified Soul: 0/1 turned in from Barbarian Gangster

**The Shadow Alchemist:
Dark Essence: 0/5 turned in from Caustic Corpse
Evil Stone: 0/3 turned in from Infuriated Savage
Consumed Soul: 0/1 turned in from Choleric Ancient

**The Holy Alchemist:
Holy Essence: 0/5 turned in from Fallen Angel
Consecrated Glyph: 0/3 turned in from Apparitional Veteran
Pure Soul: 0/1 turned in from Rabid Wallabee

The Fire Alchemist:
Fiery Essence: 0/5 turned in from haunters **
Rock of Eternal Flame: 0/3 turned in from Lost Demon **
Conflagrated Soul: 0/1 turned in from Forgotten Warrior

The Kinetic Alchemist:
Pure Black Jet: 0/1 turned in from Entropic Horror **
Flame Scarred Ruby: 0/1 turned in
Pure Kinetic Diamond: 0/1 turned in from Entropic Horror
Mysterious Sapphire: 0/1 turned in
Heavenly Emerald: 0/1 turned in

Rewards are potions that help you beat the new guardians
The Shadow Alchemist = Shadowy Weapon
The Arcane Alchemist = Arcane Weapon
The Fire Alchemist = Fiery Weapon
The Kinetic Alchemist = Kenetic Weapon
The Holy Alchemist = Holy Weapon